Court Challenge Could Again Reshape Federal Joint Employer Standard

Posted By: Tim O'Connor Latest News, Advocacy Updates,

A federal appeals court heard oral arguments on Monday, Nov. 16, in a lawsuit that could once again widen the government’s definition of a joint employer.

The case, Service Employees International Union (SEIU) v. National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), was originally filed in 2021 to challenge the first Trump administration’s joint employment rule. At the time, the NLRB adopted a narrower definition that stated a company could only be considered a joint employer if it possessed and exercised substantial, direct, and immediate control over at least one essential term and condition of employment. The lawsuit was paused in 2023 after the Biden-led NLRB issued a new joint employer standard that included any entity that had a right to exercise control, including indirect control, over an employee. A U.S. district court vacated that version of the rule in 2024, and the NLRB formalized the return to the direct control standard in March 2026.

With the 2020 definition back in place, SEIU revived the lawsuit. The union argues in its filing that the NLRB’s joint employer rule did not go far enough when it defined “terms and conditions of employment” as only wages, benefits, hours, scheduling, assignment of duties, supervision, discipline, hiring and firing, and working conditions related to the safety and health of employees. The standard arbitrarily excludes health and safety issues from consideration, SEIU stated, a “particularly egregious” omission in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, which was still affecting workplace conditions at the time of the original filing.

During oral arguments before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, lawyers representing SEIU expanded on their theory, stating that the 2020 version of the rule does not adequately consider reserved or indirect control when determining whether an entity is a joint employer. SEIU told the court that the current test for joint employer status is structured to ensure that reserved control will “never play an outcome-determinative role in any joint employer analysis.”

At least some judges appeared to agree with SEIU’s position, stating that the union only needs to show that reserved authority is a relevant factor in deciding whether an organization is a joint employer.

Judges also questioned why the NLRB’s list of essential terms and conditions of employment did not include “health and safety” as its own item but rather placed it within the broader “working conditions.” The NLRB explained that it left health and safety off the list because businesses often enforce safety requirements just to even enter their premises. Omitting that as part of the joint employer test was intended to avoid turning these types of ordinary demands into grounds for recognizing a business as a joint employer. “The board can leave it off the list because in trying to accommodate the various interest at the table, In trying to understand the ubiquity of safety measures when you’re working at someone else’s premises for another employer, it was impractical and certainly not arbitrary or capricious,” NLRB representatives said.

A decision on the lawsuit is expected sometime in the coming months. If judges rule against the NLRB, it could revert the joint employer rule to the Obama-era Browning-Ferris Industries standard, which included companies that have indirect control over employees.

Business advocacy groups, including FEDA, have favored the direct control definition because it clearly defines which organizations are responsible for an employee’s terms and conditions of employment. It also prevents employers from being required to participate in collective bargaining for employees they may not directly control. FEDA has also supported the Save Local Business Act, a bill that would codify the direct control standard by amending the National Labor Relations Act and the Fair Labor Standards Act.